Concept

Provisional Existence

Definition

Provisional existence is the phrase Frankl used to describe how a concentration-camp prisoner experienced time: as a life on hold, temporary, and — most corrosively — with no foreseeable end. He called it a provisional existence of unknown limit. A prisoner could not know whether the ordeal would last another week, another year, or until death.

The phrase names a specific psychological condition, recorded as testimony from inside the camps. It is not a metaphor for ordinary uncertainty. It describes what happens to a person when their existence is suspended indefinitely and they cannot see its edge.

Why it matters

How it works

Frankl noted that a person can bear almost any how of suffering if they have a why and an end in view. Provisional existence removes the end. Because the prisoner could not see when, or whether, the ordeal would close, they could not orient toward a future — and a life that cannot reach toward the future begins to lose its grip on the present.

He described prisoners who regarded their camp life as so provisional that they ceased to treat it as real life at all. That detachment was dangerous: a person who no longer counts their existence as real stops acting to preserve it. Provisional existence thus undermined the inner resources that survival depended on.

Where it goes next

Continue exploring

Tags