The attempt to redefine a correlative (one of two mutually exclusive options) so that one alternative encompasses the other, i.e.
Examples:
- _Rick: I need to know if we should stop for lunch or not. You are either hungry or not hungry, which is it?
Tina: If being hungry is being able to eat, I am always hungry._
Synonyms: fallacy of lost contrast, fallacy of the suppressed relative