The Majesty of the Law (Part 1 of 3)

Core idea

The 1924 referendum had approved the $15 million park bond, but the money would not flow until 1925. Moses could not wait. He moved at once to physically seize the lands he wanted — the Taylor Estate (Heckscher Park), the Whitman Estate, scattered tracts on the Northern State and Southern State Parkway routes — by appropriation order under the buried powers in his commission's enabling statute. The barons of Long Island understood instantly what was happening and went to court. The topic takes its title from Commodore Vanderbilt's snarl: Law? What do I care for law? Hain't I got the power? The barons thought it described them. Moses meant it about himself.

Why it matters

Appropriation by survey — the buried clause activated

Moses had inserted into the 1924 enabling statute a clause that gave the commission the power to take property for the purposes of survey and then convert the survey-taken land into permanent acquisition. Pauchogue, Inc., owners of the Taylor Estate, sued for an injunction in December 1924. Moses kept building. By the time Judge Furman ruled, the Heckscher pool was already half-dug.

The Pauchogue suit

Pauchogue's lawyers argued the appropriation was illegal because no actual survey had been conducted; the commission had simply seized the land. Suffolk County Court agreed and enjoined the commission December 31, 1924. Moses ignored the injunction. By spring 1925 the Court of Appeals would consider the case. Moses bet that he could build faster than the courts could decide.

Key takeaways

Mental model

Copy sourceZoom

Practical application

Example

Robert Moses used this principle for forty years; Elon Musk has used a version of it at SpaceX in Boca Chica (building before FAA permits cleared); Israeli settlement policy in the West Bank uses it at national scale. The facts-on-the-ground heuristic outlives the people who invented it.

Related lessons