Age of Optimism (Part 2 of 2)

Core idea

The second half of Age of Optimism watches the plan die in detail and follows Moses through the empty months afterward. By late 1917, with Mitchel defeated and Tammany back, Moses was a 28-year-old reformer with no organization, no income, and no plan. The topic ends in 1918 with Moses living off Mary's small savings, taking minor consulting work, reading military history at night. It is the inflection point: the next topic introduces Belle Moskowitz, who will end the dry spell by bringing him to Al Smith.

Why it matters

The plan dies the way most legislation dies — without a vote

Amendments watered it into uselessness; a public hearing was dominated by uniformed sanitation workers shouting at aldermen; the New York World editorialized against it. By November 1917, when Mitchel lost to Tammany's John F. Hylan, the plan was already moribund. Hylan formally shelved it January 1918.

The end of the reformer Moses

Caro signals that the man who emerged from 1918 was no longer the man who entered 1913. The Oxford blueprint was now a private resentment. The Bureau colleagues were men who had let him down. The reformers were now do-gooders. The operational vocabulary of the rest of his career was assembled here in the empty year.

Key takeaways

Mental model

Copy sourceZoom

Practical application

Example

Compare to Winston Churchill's 'wilderness years' (1929-1939), spent out of cabinet, writing, brooding on Germany. The vocabulary he assembled — appeasement, gathering storm, finest hour — defined the rest of his career. Empty years produce vocabulary. The vocabulary defines the next topic.

Related lessons