Burning (Part 2 of 2)

Core idea

The second half of Burning zooms inside Moses the person: working sixteen-hour days at the Bureau, increasingly impatient with colleagues he found slow, increasingly contemptuous of consensus, and meeting Mary Louise Sims, a Bureau secretary who would become his wife in 1915. The topic shows the personal cost of the first phase of his career — long years of unrewarded work, slow accumulation of resentment, and the marriage that gave him a stable home base from which to fight battles he could not yet win.

Why it matters

Sixteen-hour days for nothing

Moses was paid almost nothing at the Bureau. He lived in a small flat on West 87th Street, took the subway downtown, worked until midnight, and watched his classification plan grind through committees that diluted it. He resented the dilution. He resented the committees. He began to develop the conviction — never afterward weakened — that committees were where ideas went to die.

Mary Sims, the marriage that lasted

Mary Louise Sims was a Bureau secretary. Anglo-Irish Catholic, lower-middle-class, undramatic, devoted. They married in 1915. Bella was furious — Mary was not Jewish, not wealthy, not Our Crowd. Robert married anyway. The marriage lasted until Mary's death in 1966. Caro presents Mary as the human cost-bearer of Moses's career: she would raise the two daughters essentially alone.

The first crack — Moses begins to mistrust reformers

By 1917 Moses had begun to suspect that the reformers he had spent four years with — Bruère, Beard, the gentlemen of the Bureau — were too gentlemanly to win. The word he reached for to describe them was the same one he had used about the Yale swim coach: unreasonable. He had not yet found a new political home. But he had stopped believing in the one he was in.

Key takeaways

Mental model

Copy sourceZoom

Practical application

The deeper warning: personal cost — the marriages, the missed years — accumulates without producing the wisdom that would have made it worth bearing. Moses paid the price and learned the wrong lesson.

Example

Larry Summers's tenure at Treasury and Harvard shows the same fork. After each failure (LTCM, Russian privatization, the Harvard presidency) Summers had the choice to conclude I missed something the affected people knew or the affected people were the problem. He repeatedly chose the second. The personal toll mounted; the wisdom did not.

Related lessons